Gas vs. Electric Fireplace

For many reasons, not everyone wants to have a traditional wood fireplace. It can be the pain of cleaning, an asthmatic family member, or simply a house full of kids. For homeowners who wish to have a fireplace without burning wood, the common dilemma is: Gas or electric fireplace? 

Both options offer distinct advantages, but the right choice depends on factors like budget, installation requirements, aesthetics, and intended use. In our past guide, we briefly covered the differences between traditional wood-burning, gas, and electric fireplaces. In this article, we do an in-depth comparison between gas and electric fireplaces, their pros and cons, and running costs. We’ll also discuss which fireplace option might be the better fit based on individual circumstances.

Gas Fireplaces

A gas fireplace uses propane or natural gas as the fuel source instead of wood. It comes in vented and ventless versions.

Gas fireplaces use gas logs to imitate the look of a traditional fireplace.

Pros

✔ Real Flame Experience

Gas fireplaces offer the look and feel of a real fire with visible flames, often preferred by those who want the traditional fireplace experience.

✔ Higher Heat Output

Gas fireplaces generally provide more heat compared to electric ones. They can warm large spaces and may even serve as a secondary heat source in colder climates.

Featured high-output gas log set with burner:

RH Peterson Real-Fyre Charred American Oak Log Set – Choice of Vented Burner and Valve Kit

Modeled from real oak log samples, the Charred American Oak log set, is hand painted for that unique, realistic look you are looking for. The charred accents added to this log set add a natural look to the logs. Each log has reinforced steel rods inserted to improve durability.

They are available in 18″ (CHAO18), 24″ (CHAO24) and 30″ (CHAO30). The 18″ log set includes 6 hand painted, steel-reinforced logs and the 24″ and 30″ log sets each include 7 beautifully crafted logs. The front log in all sets is actually made up of 2 individual log pieces. The space between the front logs gives the illusion of a recently burned out log for a most realistic look in your gas fireplace.

RH Peterson offers several vented burners and valve options with the set.

✔ Quick and Efficient Heat

With the flick of a switch, a gas fireplace can produce immediate heat, making it ideal for those who want a quick warmth boost without waiting.

✔ Variety of Styles

Gas fireplaces come in various styles, from modern to rustic. They can be installed in traditional wood-burning fireplace settings or designed as stand-alone units.

Featured rustic traditional fireplace style:

Majestic TRILLIANT35I 35″ Trilliant Series Premium Direct Vent Fireplace Insert with Intermittent Pilot System

The Trilliant35 boasts a maximum output of 35,000 BTUs with a minimum of 24,500 BTUs. It includes an 8 piece ceramic fiber log set and a built-in burner with intermittent pilot ignition. The burner is fully recessed so your fireplace will be filled with lively flames.

Optional accessories include a WiFi module, and a black glass liner.

✔ Lower Running Costs (Natural Gas)

If you already have a natural gas connection, running a gas fireplace can be more economical in the long run compared to electric models, especially in colder regions.

---

Cons

Complex Installation
Installing a gas fireplace often requires professional assistance. Venting is necessary for most models, and homes without an existing gas line will need to install one, adding to the cost.

Higher Initial Costs

Gas fireplaces typically come with a higher upfront cost due to installation needs, such as venting, gas connections, and structural work.

Maintenance Needs

Gas fireplaces require regular maintenance and inspections to ensure safe operation. There’s a need to monitor venting, gas lines, and clean burners periodically.

Potential Safety Concerns

Although gas fireplaces are generally safe, there’s always a small risk of gas leaks or combustion-related accidents if they are not maintained properly.

---

Electric Fireplaces

An electric fireplace uses electricity to generate heat. Since it does not produce an actual flame, the flames are simulated by an LCD screen. In recent years, flame technology has improved drastically and many electric fireplaces are able to replicate a real flame accurately.

Pros

✔ Ease of Installation

Electric fireplaces are easy to install, often requiring nothing more than plugging them into a standard electrical outlet. No venting or gas line installation is needed, making them a perfect option for renters or those seeking a quick upgrade.

Entry level electric fireplace:

Dimplex BFSL33 33″ Slim Line Built-In Electric Firebox

Don’t let its budget price fool you: this built-in fireplace features a large 33-inch wide viewing area that makes it look more expensive than its price tag! It uses Dimplex’s patented LED technology to produce a remarkably realistic illusion of a true fire. A bed of hand-finished logs molded from real wood logs offer incredible realism, fused with pulsating electric embers for a gorgeous, rustic look. 

This firebox is safe to use and economically and environmentally efficient, producing no harmful particulates or emissions into the air and running perfectly on minimal energy, costing just pennies a day. The heater is also designed to heat a room up to 400 square feet, providing supplemental heat when required.

✔ Low Maintenance

Electric fireplaces don’t involve combustion, so they don’t produce smoke, ash, or soot. Maintenance is limited to occasional dusting and checking electrical connections.

✔ Safer Operation

With no real flame or gas involved, electric fireplaces pose fewer safety risks. There’s no risk of gas leaks, and the units remain cool to the touch, making them safer for homes with children and pets.

✔ Flexible Placement

Since they don’t require ventilation, electric fireplaces can be installed in virtually any room, including basements, apartments, and smaller spaces where gas options might not be feasible.

Compact electric fireplace that can be installed in tight spaces:

Simplifire SF-INS30 30″ Electric Fireplace Insert

This electric fireplace insert is the perfect solution for you unused, masonry fireplace*. This 30″ electric fireplace insert features a traditional wood-burning fireplace design. This 30″ fireplace allows a nice size viewing area at 27″ x 16.25″.

It features a detailed masonry style design and a log set. The fireplace can be used year round with or without heat and offers several display functions as well. The heater offers low and high settings which are thermostat adjustable – the temperature adjusts the heaters response to the ambient temperature conditions in the room 60°F – 82°F.  It also has a timer function up to 9 hours in 1 hour increments. Additionally the flame adjustment offers four flame effects. 

The electric fireplace insert includes a front frame for an appealing, finished look without adding a surround. However, two sizes of optional surrounds are available.

✔ Cost-Effective for Smaller Spaces

Electric fireplaces are more economical for heating smaller spaces or for providing supplemental heat to specific rooms rather than an entire home.

---

Cons

Lower Heat Output

Electric fireplaces don’t generate as much heat as gas models, making them less suitable for larger spaces or as a primary heat source in colder climates.

Power Requirement

Electric fireplaces won’t work during a power outage, which can be a drawback in areas prone to electrical disruptions.

Higher Running Costs

Depending on electricity rates, running an electric fireplace for extended periods can be more expensive than gas, particularly in regions where electricity costs are high.

Acquisition and Running Costs

Gas Fireplace

Acquisition Cost: The upfront cost of purchasing and installing a gas fireplace ranges from $2,500 to $5,000, depending on the complexity of installation and the type of venting system.

Running Cost: Gas fireplaces cost approximately $0.25 to $1.00 per hour to operate, with natural gas generally being cheaper than propane. However, the exact cost depends on local gas prices and usage patterns.

Maintenance Costs: Routine maintenance is required, including annual inspections of gas lines and vents, which can add to the long-term expense.

Click here for an in-depth guide to the full costs of a gas fireplace, including gas logs and accessories.

Electric Fireplace

Acquisition Cost: Electric fireplaces are less expensive, typically ranging from $200 to $5,000. Since they don’t require venting or gas lines, installation costs can be minimal. Installation can be more complicated for a modern looking linear fireplace.

Running Cost: Electric fireplaces cost around $0.20 to $0.40 per hour to run, depending on electricity rates and the model’s energy efficiency.

Maintenance Costs: Maintenance costs are minimal, as electric fireplaces only require basic cleaning and occasional electrical inspections.

When is a Gas Fireplace More Suitable?

✔ Larger Rooms or Open Spaces

Gas fireplaces excel at heating larger areas and can serve as a supplementary heat source in colder climates, where high heat output is necessary.

✔ Traditional Aesthetic

If the goal is to mimic a traditional wood-burning fireplace, gas offers a much closer experience with real flames and a warmer, more authentic ambiance.

✔ Homes with Existing Gas Lines

If your home already has natural gas, installing a gas fireplace may be more cost-effective in the long run due to the lower cost of fuel.

✔ Off-the-Grid or Power Outage Backup

A gas fireplace can operate independently of electricity, making it a reliable heat source during power outages.

When is an Electric Fireplace More Suitable?

✔ Smaller Rooms or Apartments

Electric fireplaces are perfect for smaller spaces where heating needs are modest, such as bedrooms, apartments, or offices.

✔ Modern Style Without Heat

Many electric fireplaces can operate with heating turned off so you can have the appearance of a warm flame even in the middle of summer.

✔ Quick Installation

For homeowners or renters seeking a hassle-free installation, electric fireplaces offer a plug-and-play solution with no need for venting or gas lines.

✔ Installation Location

Electric models come in a wide range of contemporary designs and can be installed almost anywhere, providing design flexibility that gas fireplaces may not offer.

✔ Safety Considerations

Homes with children, pets, or individuals concerned about combustion safety may prefer the safer, cool-to-the-touch design of electric fireplaces.

Conclusion

Both gas and electric fireplaces offer unique benefits, and the best choice depends on your home, heating needs, and aesthetic preferences. 

Gas fireplaces are ideal for those seeking high heat output, traditional fire experiences, and long-term efficiency, especially in homes with existing gas lines. On the other hand, electric fireplaces shine in smaller spaces, with easier installation, greater safety, and minimal maintenance. 

Once you’ve carefully considered the pros and cons and your needs, check out our extensive line of gas fireplaces, including gas logs and accessories. We also offer a wide range of electric fireplace models, as well as inserts and related parts and accessories.